Star Wars in my opinion is just "ok". It passed the time and was fun for me over the holidays as my schedule at work now does not allow me to raid in Rift. I liked raiding in Rift, but for me if I can't raid in a game I get bored.
I agree with Booie that Star Wars is wow in space, but in terms of UI and response times it is not as fast as wow, but not as slow as Rift. The questing is at times better due to cutscenes but at times worst as you may get bored with them and skip the story.
My motivation is being in an Aussie raiding guild that raids in the evening my time but I could just as easily have transferred my Rift toon to an Oceanic server to do the same. The only reason I did not do that was because I like Gaiscioch and hope that at some point either my schedule will change or Rift will add something other than raids to keep me interested.
Star Wars is not bad, but not great either...it does not break any ground, it has positives and negatives making it ok but perhaps not a game you would like to play for years. I am reserving further judgement until I raid and work out what endgame pve is like. I prefer the pvp in SW because Huttball is funny and the fire traps are cool. However there is no bracket system so you are pvping against level 50s which can be annoying.
I like the crafting because you send your companions off to do it. I like the instances because you only need 4 people and 2 of those can be your pets, so it is good to level with just one or two friends.
I like the space missions because they are like old skool super nintendo star wars x-wing games and are pretty quick to finish.
I like my Sith inquisitor's zappy fingers, but I am healing mostly and healing is pretty boring with a flash heal, greater heal, one hot and one shield. I tend to dps and heal to make it more fun.
On the down sides the voice acting is terrible, the story was done so much better in Mass Effect 2 and the UI is missing basics like target of target and the ability to customise much.
That is just my opinion, and I am only really playing it because I have time on my hands over the holidays :)
» Edited on: 2012-01-07 16:21:57