Pre BWE 1, I was certain my main would be a Charr mesmer. GW1 I was a mesmer and loved it. In all other MMO's to date I have always played a dwarf and prior to joining Gaiscioch in WAR I was in an all dwarf guild that spanned multiple games (shout out to Warfield and Stone and Steel) so I was dead set against the Asura on principle. I had decided they were the race that killed dwarfs for GW2, so they were out! (I know this isn't true, but in my brain, I had it all worked out that the Asura were the villains and scapegoats.)
Then BWE 2 came around and I discovered the engineer class. My Charr mesmer was slowly becoming a Charr Engineer with a mesmer in the back up position. I tried nearly all the other professions and also started feeling the necromancer. I was anti- warrior, thief and ranger after trying them and didn't even pick up the elementalist.
It was looking like 1. Engineer 2. Mesmer 3. Guardian. I figured I'd have one from every group.
Enter BWE 3. Oh man. Big trouble. Played Engineer. Asuran Engineer. BAM! Done. Put it in the bank. BLASPHEMY!!! I'm a dwarf fan. I hate all things non-dwarf. The Asura are a mockery of fantasy dwarfs! Ugly little Lilo and Stitch Disney rejects! But something about the way they are written, the way their starting area and lore is brought to life in GW2 sucked me in.
So much so, I rolled three other Asuran characters and a Sylvari Mesmer to try out over the course of the weekend.
Okay: Sylvari are cool looking. Character creation is top notch. But just as my Dwarf fondness over 20 years of gaming has caused me both dis- trust and like of Elves, something about the Sylvari turn me off. Damned dirty Asura!! I'm chalking it up, partly, to the fact that I think I'm coming to terms with the fact that as much as I love my GW1 mesmer, the GW2 variety just doesn't play the same...and the cool looking Weirwood inspired white Sylvari with red leafy hair and red bio-glow couldn't turn me around this BWE. I want to love the mesmer again almost as much as I want to hate the Asura. Grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.
So Asuran Engineer is in the one spot. I gave the guardian and necro another spin each (only to lvl 11) and was sort of warming to both of them. So I thought in fairness, I should give the Warrior another whirl and since I hadn't even bothered in two BWEs, I should at least whip up an elementalist (though I had ZERO interest in playing one. Ever.)
And then it happened. Stupid Asuran warrior was crazy fun in PvE. Like the most fun I've had runnin' around in a video game in a long time fun. I could shoot stuff, I could stab stuff, I could smash stuff... and all the while looking like some cross between an ancient Mayan and the aliens responsible for their extinct civilization. I liked it so much my list started looking like.
1. Engineer (Asuran.)
2. Warrior ((A) Asuran, (B) Norn, (C) Charr)...thinking I need to experience a different personal story line I should deviate from Asuran.
3. Scholar class - ((A) Mesmer, (B) Necro.
Yeah, you know where this is going. Stupid Elementalist. Just as much fun as the warrior, but completely different. Where the warrior switches weapon combos, the elementalist swaps attunements. Wanna be up in someone's grill with the ele? Go for it. Wanna stand back and nuke. Knock yourself out. Support? Yes, please.
So to sum up this novella and to answer the original query:
BWE1 1. Charr Mesmer
2. Norn Guardian
3. Sylvari Necromancer
4. TBD
5. TBD
POST BWE3: 1. Asuran Engineer
2. Asuran Warrior
3. Gods help me... could be an Asuran Elementalist.
4. TBD
5. TBD